Why manufacturing modernization projects stall, and how to get them moving | Velotic

Introducing the Industrial AI Value Cube – a practical framework for moving beyond pilots to measurable value.  Explore the framework

Why manufacturing modernization projects stall, and how to get them moving

Why do manufacturing modernization projects stall? Explore common digital transformation challenges and how to align technology, people, and business outcomes.

Blog 10 min read

Expert perspective: Paul Adams

Paul Adams, Director of Partner Programs, Americas at Velotic, works closely with system integrators to understand the challenges manufacturers face. In this three-part series, he shares insights from conversations with four industry partners about data readiness, manufacturing modernization, and the evolving role of system integrators.

Why Modernization Initiatives Stall

Why modernization initiatives stall

When manufacturers launch modernization programs, they often assume the primary challenges will be technical. In reality, modernization requires much more than deploying new technology.

To better understand what prevents these initiatives from delivering lasting value, I spoke with four system integration partners: John Leppiaho of Leveraging Manufacturing Solutions (LMS), Andy Corsini of E Tech Group, Justin Vaught of RoviSys, and Tod Virden of Gray Matter Systems. Their experiences highlight the importance of planning, organizational alignment, and understanding how technology will support the people who use it.

Why Technology Alone Isn’t Enough

Why technology alone isn’t enough

According to Leppiaho, "Projects most often get stuck because risks aren't addressed early enough through proper planning and change management."

Organizations frequently encounter challenges related to data accessibility, data quality, operational context, systems integration, user adoption, and stakeholder alignment. While these challenges may appear at different stages of a modernization initiative, addressing them requires more than technical expertise.

Justin Vaught sees organizational change management as one of the most common reasons modernization initiatives struggle to achieve lasting success. "User adoption and OCM continue to be our biggest challenge."

He notes that employees naturally distrust new technologies, resist change, and often revert to existing processes once implementation teams leave. As Vaught puts it, "A technically successful implementation that nobody uses is not a successful project."

Digital Maturity Is More Than Technology

Digital maturity is more than technology

One of the most overlooked aspects of data readiness is organizational maturity. Many manufacturers focus heavily on systems and infrastructure while overlooking how people consume, interpret, and act on information.

Leppiaho cautions that siloed decision-making can exist even in organizations with highly connected systems. "A customer can have highly connected systems and still operate in silos if the organization hasn't developed the processes, skills, and behaviors to turn that data into actionable information."

Virden emphasizes the importance of operational and technical preparedness. For him, a data-ready manufacturer is one that has modernized control systems to support data sharing, established secure OT network architectures, and implemented strategies for aggregating information closer to the edge. Just as importantly, those organizations have manufacturing engineers, IT partners, and business leaders actively engaged in determining how operational information will be used to improve business outcomes.

Vaught reinforces the importance of looking beyond technology: "Being data-ready is not simply a technology architecture. It is a combination of people, process, data, and technology, with a clear connection back to business outcomes."

When Manufacturers Stop Trusting Their Data

When manufacturers stop trusting their data

Even when the necessary systems are in place, poor data quality and missing operational context can undermine confidence in modernization efforts.

Corsini highlights the consequences when that foundation is missing. "When data is of poor quality or lacks context, manufacturers can stop trusting the data and ultimately revert to less efficient, more manual methods to help make their decisions."

Vaught sees the same pattern. "People stop trusting the data. When that happens, they create their own workarounds: paper capture, spreadsheets, time studies, manual checks, and manual reporting."

Once confidence in data erodes, the value of digital transformation begins to erode with it. Organizations that achieve the greatest success are often not those with the newest technology stack. They are the organizations that have established a trusted, scalable, and contextualized data foundation.

Start With Business Outcomes, Not Technology

Start with business outcomes, not technology

One of the most common mistakes manufacturers make is approaching digital transformation as a technology initiative. New platforms are selected, data is connected, and dashboards are deployed. Yet the business outcomes remain unclear.

Leppiaho recommends reversing that approach. "Start with the business outcome and the personas who need to achieve it. Understand what decisions they need to make, what actions they need to take, and what data and context will help them do that better. Then apply the technology."

Technology should enable transformation. It should not define it. Vaught has observed that many digital transformation efforts make the same mistake: "Focusing on the technology before clearly defining the problem they are trying to solve."

Virden frequently sees a similar pattern. "Manufacturers often want to start using data or jump into a project before defining the business outcomes they hope to achieve." Without clear objectives, organizations risk building architectures, integrations, and dashboards that generate activity without creating measurable operational value.

Involve the People Who Will Use the Technology

Involve the people who will use the technology

Vaught also cautions against excluding end users from solution design. "If the end users aren't involved in the process, you can build something technically impressive that doesn't fit the way the operation actually works."

Leppiaho reinforces the importance of involving people throughout the modernization process. "Modernization is rarely just a technology project; it requires alignment between the technology, processes, data, and the people who ultimately have to use it."

Without that alignment, even well-funded initiatives can struggle to deliver lasting value. Manufacturers need to look beyond the implementation itself and consider how new technologies will fit into everyday operations, support the people using them, and help achieve the business outcomes that justified the investment in the first place.

Continue Reading: Building Connected, Data-Ready Operations

Continue reading: Building connected, data-ready operations

Successful modernization requires more than the right technology. Manufacturers also need the expertise to connect systems, align stakeholders, and develop practical roadmaps that support long-term business objectives.

In the final article of this series, we explore how system integrators help manufacturers bridge the gap between IT and OT, develop scalable architectures, and build more connected, data-ready operations.

 

With thanks to our system integrator partners

Move from AI ambition to operational value

Successful AI initiatives take more than technology. Discover five prerequisites for progress and a practical framework for aligning investments with business outcomes.

Explore industrial AI

Continue reading